Showing posts with label Homeopathy. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Homeopathy. Show all posts

A day with James Randi

A long time ago I watched Johnny Carson's guest "The Amazing" James Randi on the Tonight Show, as Randi exposed Peter Popoff and conducted "psychic surgery" on a willing Tonight Show audience member.

Mr. Randi was so entertaining that I immediately liked him. But that was just the impression I got of him from television. I wondered if he was different in real life.

Today, I had the chance to put that to the test, in a style that I hope Randi would approve. I got to meet him, share breakfast, talk with him and listen to his wisdom. And I have to say that I was right, Mr. Randi IS different in real life than on television. On television, Randi is merely an entertaining and interesting person who comes across as a nice guy too.

In real life, Randi is all of that, cubed and squared again!

First, I'm impressed with how quick he is mentally. It's hard to keep up with him. I was able to contribute a little from my specialty in Engineering (Remember Randi, don't cut the RED or the BLACK wires! You need them for your iPhone!)

And I think it might be difficult to keep up with Randi even physically. I didn't have much opportunity to test that theory, but the sense I got was that he was full of boundless energy, like the energizer bunny.

I did get a signature on my copy of Randi's book Flim-Flam! This book came out back in 1982. I purchased this book back in 1997 when I was starting my journey in deconverting to become an Ex-Christian.

When I was growing up, I was a believer in a lot of things. Besides being a Christian, I believed in things like psychic phenomena and dowsing. This book kicked a large hole in the side of my woo-woo beliefs. And it gave a thirst to learn more.

It was books such as this that gave me my start in real rational thinking.

I've been gratified to compare things on his speech today to the things I've been doing as a skeptic. My best comparison is that I tested Randi's claim that the Counterfeit Detection Pen was pretty much useless.

Even today, two years after my original post on the detection pen, I still get several hundred hits a month on that page, and I'm in the top Google results for "DriMark Counterfeit Detection Pens". Not too bad.

And while my pages on Homeopathy are still as relevant as I first wrote them, Randi told us about some twists that might help my readers better visualize the sheer scales involved in Homeopathy, and from his information, I realized I need to make my Homeopathy page more current.

I took some time to take a short QIK video of Randi during his speech this evening, but I realized almost immediately that it was the wrong tool for the job, so I stopped. Still, you can see the video that I do have here.

All in all, it was a good day today, a day that started with, and ended with James Randi. Any day like that is a Good Day!


Still, there is a sad note that I must end on.

Peter Popoff went out of business because Randi exposed his lies. He was a liar for Jesus, and what he was doing was immoral. James Randi gave him a good drubbing on the Tonight Show, and he almost immediately went out of business. You would have thought he would have stayed out of business. But that hasn't been the case.

Peter Popoff is back, and not only is he back, but he is doing the same thing that he was doing way back then, with one exception. Now he makes MORE money at it than he did before Randi exposed him. Take a look at this:

Homeopathy failed me - Willow Bark to the rescue!

You know, I meant to post over the last few days. Unfortunately I caught a really bad flu. I had a fever of 102 on Saturday.

I tried finding a Homeopathic fever remedy to bring down my fever - but I ran into something odd. The local drugstore didn't have any sort of Homeopathic fever remedies! I was shocked! Completely staggered! (Well, actually I was unsteady on my feet due to fever and weakness.)

I had to resort instead to an old Chinese remedy that was also (not surprisingly) used by my (distant) Choctaw forefathers. So I channeled the spirits of my ancestors and quickly made a tea of boiled willow bark and drank it, which immediately and effectively brought down my fever.

Okay, not really.

Finding the right kind of willow tree here in Fresno was way outside of my abilities. (Remember, I was staggering around a bit in a drugstore.) And since this is Fresno, the chances were good that I'd have to rip the bark off of a tree in some home owner's yard. Nothing good could come from this.

But even in my fever I intelligently recalled that the pain relieving property in willow bark is a chemical called salicin, which when metabolized becomes salicylic acid, a chemical that has an excellent track record for relieving fever.

Salicylic acid does have it's problems. It will do a number on your stomach - not to mention it has a horrible bitter taste. Those side effects bothered a lot of people, so after 40 years of a chemistry "comedy of errors" chemists at Friedrich Bayer & Co finally both synthesized acetylsalicylic acid, and realized its value. Bayer immediately marketed this finding as "Aspirin" just in time for the turn of the century. (Yes, this is the abbreviated Cliff's Notes version of the story.)

Fighting against fever I realized that I couldn't get my hands on willow bark tea. But a bottle of aspirin and a jug of orange juice was right at hand there at the pharmacy!

See? No potions, no endless Homeopathic dilutions that depend on magical formula. Merely a simple medication that has been proven to work, over and over again - every time - in double blind clinical trials.

I popped a couple of aspirin and chugged some orange juice, and my fever subsided for the evening which allowed me to get some good sleep. After about 4 days the worst of the flu (with its fever) has passed and I'm up and around again. I've even got plenty of left-over aspirin to use on other maladies - like muscle aches and headaches.

But I really did want to find that Homeopathic fever cure. Ah well. Maybe next time.

Udaya's daughter lived, therefore Homeopathy works!

Just a little over two years ago I posted a blog entry over why Homeopathy does NOT work, that it is based upon the magical principle of the "Law of Similarity", and I mentioned the problem with "water memory" that Homeopathy has.

This entry still gets a lot of traffic, and every now and then I get a comment from someone who tries, and fails, to refute it. (I keep asking for evidence, darn it!)

One commenter has asked for a more serious reply, and since I didn't wish to bury it as a comment to that article I'll bring it forward for everyone to see.

I'd like my readers to meet Udaya, from India: (You can read his original comment here)
I hope you know that in India there is a nature based system of medicine called ayurveda which follows principles that look common to those of homeopathy.

I was a skeptic of both these systems, in fact I used to be so sarcastic about ayurveda's long treatment period, that I used to say that ayurveda makes the treatment schedule so long so that you can forget what your problem was in the first place.

I dislike the alcohol smelling homeo sugar pills and had a bad image of it too.

I stumbled into homeo when my daughter who had some kind of cold and fever that just would not go away. I did try all the new medicines that allopathy based doctors suggested for her. They did not work beyond a certain point.

Then my father-in-law, less a skeptic than I was took her to a homeopathic doctor, who prescribed her a course of medicines, slightly tweaking it, or so he said, until he got it right.

I am sorry to tell you that it did work. In fact we started to keep it with us and give it to her at the first symptoms of cold. It would simply go away.

It so happened that once we did not have such medicines with us and the girl ran a high fever and cold.

The allopaths could do little, so I had to go back to the homeopath again. The problem got resolved and as she grew older the problem almost disappeared. She is seven years old now.
It's too bad that your daughter was sick, Udaya. I know the fear and frustration that occurs when someone close to you is ill or dying, especially when there is nothing you can do about it. It is enough to make a person grasp for the faintest of straws, and to consider every possible hope – no matter how unlikely. It is how our minds work – we do not like “No” for an answer.

I have seen others who have loved ones who have recovered spontaneously from illness. “Spontaneous Remission” is doctor language for, “I have no clue why he got better.” It is an honest evaluation of the situation, and an admission that no doctor, no person, completely understands human physiology. Perhaps with work that will change someday.

The problem with “spontaneous remission” is that no one can identify exactly what happened. Usually so many different treatments have been thrown at the patient that it becomes difficult to tell exactly what was effective. Was it the antibiotic the doctor gave the patient last week? Was it the enforced rest in the quiet hospital room under a morphine drip to keep the pain down that allowed the patient's body to rally? In some cases, even a placebo will allow a patient to fight the pain or to gain the confidence needed so that they don't lose the will to live.

But that does not mean that a sugar pill is the best, or right treatment.

As for Allopathy, that's a loaded word isn't it? A word loaded with scorn, given by Homeopaths toward scientific practitioners of medicine - these are the same people who call what they do, "Alternative Medicine" - like you have a choice between two good things that actually work.

In reality, there is no such thing as “Alternative Medicine” - there is either medicine, or not-medicine.

Medicine either works, again and again in the majority of patients under clinical trials – or it does not. What use is a “medicine” that works only sometimes, in shadowy and mysterious ways with only a magical explanation of why it does anything? If it does anything? It is worse than useless because you can never be sure if you are fooling yourself or not – you can't trust it.
I did try some other medicines in homeopathy; like medicines for gastritis and small problems like that and found that many a time they work better than antacids and equivalent allopathy medicines.

I have seen these ans similar arguments against homeopathy earlier in science mags and blogs and always wondered about how these medicines worked.

I finally got it down to the placebo effect. As you say the placebo effect is extremely powerful.

The only problem was that my daughter when she started on homeopathic medicines was little more than a year old. I am not sure if placebo effects work on tiny infants like that.

If they really do then why did the same effect not work when other allopathic medicines were given?

Can you please put your thinkig cap on Or do you want to refer to some FDA literature.
I would love to see some peer-reviewed literature on why Homeopathic medicine works, Udaya – but you won't find any in any mainstream medical journal. And the FDA does not give a darn about Homeopathy as long as it is no more effective than a sugar pill and as long as it does not contain harmful substances – which would of course be absent if made in accordance to Homeopathic methods!

The Federal Trade Commission in the United States regulates the labeling on the packaging, requiring that labeling cannot falsely advertise or misrepresent the product. This means that substantiating evidence is required, which Homeopathic companies never provide. That is why in the United States the packaging for a Homeopathic sleeping pill says something like, “May reduce the effect of Insomnia”, or some other weaselly words. All homeopathic packaging I've seen contains such weasel words – which could easily be removed if the manufacturer came up with evidence!

Speaking of evidence, I have found Homeopathic “medical” journals before. They all seem to start with the same premise – that Homeopathic medicines work. I have yet to see one of these journals host an article that demonstrates the effectiveness of Homeopathy in a double-blind test over a statistically significant population using rigorous and scientifically sound testing methods that are observed and agreed upon by trusted biologists and / or medical scientists.

But maybe I haven't looked hard enough. I'd appreciate it if you helped me out here.

The only observation that I can make Udaya is that Homeopathy works, if it works, by the placebo effect. Any other time that it seems to work – well, humans are good at finding patterns – even where a pattern doesn't really exist. We remember the times that something seems to work, and forget all the times that it does not. We have a profound misunderstanding of coincidence, and we tend to think that coincidence is statistically significant. This basic failure to understand math and science can unfortunately be deadly to some people.
Have you ever tried homeopathic medicines for yourself? Have you talked to people who have used such medicines?
Yes, Udaya, I did try homeopathic medicine. There is a popular sleeping pill sold in pharmacies near my house – (Calms Forte, I believe).

After reading about James Randi's "Homeopathic Suicide" stunt a couple of years ago, I decided to try it myself. I bought a bottle of 50 Homeopathic sleeping pills and took half of them about an hour before my calculus class. Surely this would have been a bad idea since I needed all of my attention focused! However, I did not feel any sleepiness during or after class. I did notice some gurgling from my stomach, but that went away with time. Perhaps I got a bad batch?
Are you aware that animals are also treated with such medicines? Is there literature that justifies not using them on animals and children?
Yes, there is plenty of literature that justifies using real medicine over Homeopathic treatments. You can start with the medical journal “Lancet” and continue reading the scientific journal “Nature”. At best, Homeopathy is found to work as good as a sugar pill.
How do you know what is the medicinal effect of Trilobite piss, Whale, Walrus, Worms or Wart Hogs without testing them yourself or having them tested?
Udaya! I can't believe you have missed my point so completely! In my entry on Homeopathy I pointed out that Homeopaths claim that “water has memory” - this is why a 30C potentization is supposed to work when statistically not even a single molecule of the original Mother Tincture still exists in the dilution!

But Homeopaths never seem concerned about clearing the memory of the water that they use in their brews! So who knows what other substances that water actually remembers? It is completely unscientific and irrational! In fact, there is no reason why water, if it remembers, can't remember everything it ever encountered over the last billion years of going through the Earth's water cycle! This includes water that “remembers” being ingested, and urinated out of Trilobites, Fish, Frogs, bugs, cows, and that old homeless guy that you encountered last year on the street!

Until Homeopaths answer how they “clear” water memory during the making of their treatments, and I mean clear it of the influence of the stainless steel mixing bowl and the glass vial it is stored in too, then there is no way to prove that drinking a Homeopathic solution is any more effective than drinking tap water! The vast majority of what both liquids “remember” is identical!
Do you know that Western scientists are trawling the forests of India and Latin America and their folklore for medicines from sources more exotic than these?

Western medicines with their double blind trials have I believe created as many and more seriosu problems for humanity then other medicines. Can I remind you of thalidomide. You must be aware of many others.
Udaya, again you reveal that you yourself have failed to adequately read the available literature. Yes, it is quite true that scientists look for unique organic chemistry throughout the world's biosphere. Scientists are the first to point out that there is a wealth of things that they don't know!

I'm surprised that you hold up thalidomide as proof that double-blind trials do not work, where in fact it was the lack of adequate testing and the rush to market by the German company Chemie Grünenthal that led to tragic births. The tragedy of thalidomide introduced in 1938 forced the FDA to change its rules regarding new medications – which is why it takes years now for a new medicine to make it to market.
I am not sure as to what you are, a doctor or just another blogger who consumes and propagates memes. Please allow yourself to be unstupid for some time.

Science is what we know. Not opinions on what we do not know. Please keep that in mind.

What you have done is to interpret based on what you know. Who do you think knows homeopathy better, half witted guys like you or others who have benefited from such quack based sciences?

So much of Indian medicine and Chinese medicine was dismissed as quackery in the fifties and sixties, yet plane loads of your people arrive in India today for Panchkarma and similar things.

Do you know that sometimes they are fed cows urine? Thinking about it is enough to give you a placebo.

This is a call for less stupidity and more consideration of the evidence. Such evidence need not always arrive in double blind trials.

I dont think that homeo or any eastern system claims that it will do well in a double blind or triple blind trial.

They have been curing people based on what is known. What Western Science can do is not to trash them but to find if something in them works.

Like say for Rauwolfia, the insanity herb, which was used by Western medicine earlier to combat hypertension...

Stick to what you know, and do not spread opinions until you have tested them yourself.

regards,

Udaya

PS: I would like to watch this response on your blog and for any comments that follow.

You can always write to me at my mail id at udayapg@rediffmail.com. take your time...
Yes, Udaya, there is stupid all over isn't there? Sure plane loads of Americans fly overseas to drink your cow's urine – remember what I said about grasping at straws? Dying people tend to do that.

And I would have thought that the election of George W. Bush to a second term in office sort of knocked a dent into the idea that Americans are infallible. No matter where you go, there are stupid people.

But perhaps you can un-stupid me, Udaya. Just explain why you believe a double-blind test is a poor way to test Homeopathic medicine, or any medicine.

Science actually works – and the methods of science can be proven again and again without the need to resort to the mystical or the supernatural. I hope you remember this the next time you get a flu shot, receive antibiotics, or type out your next attack on me on a machine that couldn't even exist if some scientist didn't have a basic understanding of Quantum Mechanics.

I'm glad your daughter got better, Udaya. Sometimes shit happens. Even good shit.

Is Michael Savage a closeted, self-hating homosexual?

That savage radio “entertainer” kook who was born Michael Alan Weiner has once again viciously attacked the LGBT community with his ravings, claiming that the “Liberal Elite” are brainwashing the country.

Look out! Black Helicopters!

Is it wrong to feel schadenfreude when Dr. Savage screws up as royally as he just did? The other day he was ranting about gay parenting and Melissa Etheridge's acceptance speech at the Academy Awards:
I don't like a woman married to a woman. It makes me want to puke. How's that? I want to vomit when I hear it. I think it's child abuse.
…

I want to puke when I hear about a woman married to a woman raising children because, frankly, I think that it's child abuse to do that to children without their permission. What does a child know? Ask them when they're 16 whether they want to be raised by two lesbians or two men. What are the two men doing behind the other wall? You think the children don't hear it?
Well, the day after that rant, Hollywood's Creative Artists Agency signed Savage on as one of their clients. Oddly enough Melissa Etheridge is another current CAA client. Two days after signing Savage, the CAA dropped him faster than a homophobe would drop a plastic dildo. The talent and literary agency is arguably the most powerful such agency in all of show business, their two commandments are to be a team player and return phone calls promptly.

I get the feeling that Weiner isn’t considered a team player. I’ll bet his calls aren’t being returned by the CAA. Too frelling bad.


Weiner has a doctorate in “nutritional ethnomedicine” from U. C. Berkeley. His 1978 dissertation documents his conviction that herbal healers in South Pacific island nations have traditional herbal medicine that can treat modern ailments. His research on the sedative kava kava became the basis for his doctorial research.

Unfortunately the good Doctor’s research took a quick turn into kookiness when he started advocating the use of Homeopathic remedies to go with his plant research.

Weiner’s homophobic rants about the gay community can be seen in a much different light after you read the 1996 study by Researchers at the University of Georgia that showed cases of sexual arousal by homophobes who viewed gay porn. Perhaps this study isn’t any indication that Savage is really a self-loathing homosexual, but I think his advocacy of coffee enemas raises more than a few questions, as does his semi-autobiographical 1983 book “Vital Signs” which is about a New York Jewish man who fights his homosexual inclinations.

I’m just waiting for the good doctor to emulate Ted Haggard’s homosexual escapade. Could happen any day now.

I could so make crude puns about Weiner’s family name at this point, but that would be like nuking fish in a barrel.

Homeopathy still doesn't work

Can I call it or what? Like I said earlier - Homeopathy doesn't work.

Here is an article of a Lancet report about a study on Homeopathy - the telling quote:
"Now doctors need to be bold and honest with their patients about homeopathy's lack of benefit, and with themselves about the failings of modern medicine to address patients' needs for personalized care."
The reason why homeopathy is so attractive is because it is more personal than the medical field in general. Homeopathic bottles on the pharmacy shelf are warm and fuzzy, and don't have all the nasty side effects of real medicine. Homeopathic practitioners are friendlier than doctors. And homeopathy promises 'cures' while medicine makes few promises.

It's no wonder that people will continue to believe in Homeopathy, no matter the evidence. Homeopathy offers guarantees - medicine does not.

Of course dead people have a really hard time complaining about failed promises.

Why Homeopathic Medicine does NOT work.

While walking through a supermarket, or health food store, or even on some random shelf of a pharmacy, you encounter something called a "Homeopathic" medicine. It swears it will cure your cold, your gout, or your aching back.

These 'medicines' seem so believable. They are professionally packaged, they carry warnings, advice on usage, and they may also have some sort of official-looking approval on them too. Will it hurt to try one?

Well, it probably won't make things any worse, unless you use a homeopathic medicine in the place of seeing a doctor.
  • What is Homeopathy? Where did it come from?
According to the Homœopathic Pharmacopœia of the United States (HPUS):
Homeopathy is the art and the science of healing the sick by using substances capable of causing the same symptoms, syndromes and conditions when administered to healthy people.

Any substance may be considered a homeopathic medicine if it has known "homeopathic provings" and/or known effects which mimic the symptoms, syndromes or conditions which it is administered to treat, and is manufactured according to the specifications of the Homœopathic Pharmacopœia of the United States (HPUS). [Emphasis mine - MB]

HPUS doesn't seem to say how Homeopathy was invented, but a brief web search turns up a German physician, Samuel Hahnemann (1755-1843). My web search also gave a clue as to why Mr. Hahnemann is not mentioned promentantly on the HPUS site; he may have had some additional ideas that were discredited by his followers.
  • How is Homeopathy supposed to work?
Well, let's just examine the that first paragraph from HPUS. The one that says that it uses "substances capable of causing the same symptoms...." I knew I heard that before - oh yea, I heard it when I used to play the game Dungeons and Dragons a long time ago. It is one of the Laws of Magic. In particular, it is called the Law of Similarity, as part of the Law of Association. See this link for details.

The Law of Similarity says that like things produce like, and that the effect resembles it's cause. Basically, what this means for Homeopathy, is that if eating a certain substance, be it plant, animal or mineral, will give a healthy person a fever, then a much smaller dose of that substance will actually heal a feverish person!
  • Why is Homepathy just a fraud?
This subject has been beaten to death by skeptics on the Internet. It is probably done best by Quackwatch. So you don't have to take my word on it, go watch as a professional puts some heavy research into it. I'm just pointing out to my family and friends how much of a waste of money this medicine is. I'll do it by adding just a bit of common sense, along with a little research.

Lets take a look at this. At the time of this writing, (Aug. 2005) GNC - a retail health suppliment company commonly found in malls, had this to say about Homeopathy:

Understanding Homeopathic Potency

1) Homeopathic remedies are prepared through a process called potentization. Potentization involves a series of systematic dilutions and successions (a forceful shaking action). Potentization is important, because it removes all risk of chemical toxicity while activating a remedy substance and enabling it to affect the body therapeutically.

2) Homeopathic pharmacies operate according to strict guidelines, to ensure that the remedies and potencies are consistent and reliable. The first step in producing a homeopathic remedy is acquiring a pure preparation of the original substance in its natural form (a solution of a mineral salt, a “mother tincture” of a plant, etc.). The original substance is then put through a measured series of dilutions, alternating with succussions, until the desired potency is made.

3) Homeopathic potencies are designated by the combination of a number and a letter (for example, 6X or 30C). The number refers to the number of dilutions the tincture has undergone within a series to prepare that remedy. The letter refers to the proportions used in each dilution of the series (the Roman numeral X means 10, and the Roman numeral C means 100), as well as the number of succussions the vial of solution undergoes in each successive stage.

4) For example: To prepare a 6X potency of Ledum palustre, one part of the Ledum mother tincture is combined in a vial with nine parts of the carrier liquid, and succussed ten times again, making a 2X solution. The process is repeated four more times, for a total of six dilutions and succussions—and the final result is a 6X potency of Ledum. (To make a 30C, one part of the tincture would be combined with ninety-nine parts of the carrier liquid and succussed 100 times in each of thirty steps.) Pellets, tablets, or powders are then medicated with the potentized liquid, or drops of the remedy are taken in liquid form.

5) The more dilutions and succussions a substance undergoes, the higher the potency will be. Higher potencies of homeopathic remedies (anything higher than 12C) have been diluted past the point that molecules of the original substance would be measurable in the solution. This is a major stumbling block for skeptics when it comes to understanding and accepting the idea of homeopathy. Homeopathic remedies, when correctly chosen, clearly work—but not in the way that drugs do (through chemical actions that affect the body processes). It is not completely understood why potentized remedies can work so deeply and specifically, but many likely theories have arisen through research and observation. It appears that they function on an energetic level to stimulate the body to heal itself more efficiently.
[Paragraph numbers added by me for critiquing purposes. - MB]

Let's take this one paragraph at a time and see what they are saying -

  1. The process of potentization is defined for us as, "a series of systematic dilutions and successions." Successions is defined for us as, "a forceful shaking action." So what GNC is saying here is that the original substance is added to something to dilute it, and then shaken to mix up the resulting mixture.
  1. This second paragraph doesn't hold much meaning - they start with a "pure preparation" of the orginal substance in it's natural form? If a plant gives you a fever, then what part of the plant do they use? The leaves? The whole plant? A specially derived oil from the plant? How do they seperate one organic compound from another? The vagueness here is not reassuring to me. Then they start diluting and shaking the results.
  1. Okay, here is a bit better information. Dilution is designated by number and letter. 6X means 60 potentizations and 30C means 3000 potentizations, at least I think this is so. At this point I assume that more potentizations means that the substance is increasingly weaker, right?
  1. This part was confusing to me. It doesn't tell exactly how each potentization is put together. It seems intentionally vague. Let's see if we can figure it out. GNC says that one part of the Ledum mother tincture is combined with 9 parts of a carrier liquid. (A 'tincture' is a solution created by dissolving the target material in alchohol.) So that equals 10 parts, or 1X according to the rules of Homeopathic marking.
And then they say it is, "...successed ten times again, making a 2X solution." What? This has to be a misprint. Shaking the material 10 times will not double the solution! Maybe GNC has a misprint here?

In February of 2004 I checked the Ralph's Grocery and Pharmacy department's online Health Guide, and found an article titled, "Understanding Homeopathic Potency." But that wasn't any help because I got the same wording. It seems that GNC and Ralphs both get their information from a company called "Healthnotes." But by spring of 2005, Ralph's had taken their explanation down. Now they don't seem to explain the "How" of Homeopathy.

So while casting around the Internet, I came across a recommended site called HomeoInfo. On their page titled, "The System of Scales and Brackets" I found this about Tinctures:
Tincture
According to the preparation methods in the HPUS, all tinctures are 1/10 plant strength so the raw mother tincture is a 1X. The next step is to make a 2X. Since the 2X is a dilution of 1/100 it is the same as a 1C. From there you can do 1:9 to get X potencies and 1:99 to get the C's.

Some are marked MT for mother tincture and others have the symbol Ø to show that it is a tincture.

What I understand this to actually mean is that one part of the original material is added to 9 parts of alchohol to make the mother tincture (MT). This is labeled 1X. It is at a strength of 1 part in 10.

To make a 2X, you may need to change your method a little.


The first method would be to take one-tenth of the original mother tincture and add it to 9 parts of carrier liquid.

The second method would be to just use the whole 1X solution as a 'part' and add it to an equally sized 9 parts of carrier liquid.

I have reason to believe that the first method is used instead of the second, due to sheer quantity of the resulting solution. So lets use the first method of measuring that I describe.

To make a 2X solution, you take one part of the original 1X solution and add it to 9 parts of carrier liquid. At this point there is one part of original material dissolved into 99 parts of solution. Looks like you don't have to worry about the alchohol in the orignal solution anymore - this stuff is only 2 Proof!


But wait! They talk about a solution that is labeled 30C! How do we figure this out? Let's do some math.
If 1X = 1:9, Then we can say there are 10 total parts of solution, or 101.
So 2X = 1:99, Then we can say there are 100 total parts of solution, or 102.

AND

If 1C = 1:99, Then we can say there are 100 total parts of solution, or 1001.
So 2C = 1:9999, Then we can say there are 10000 total parts of solution, or 1002

SO
30C = 10030
. Which is 1 part of the mother tincture dissolved into
999,999,999,999,999,999,999,999,999,999,999,999,999,999,999,999,
999,999,999,999 parts of the carrier liquid!
If we were to use the second method that I describe, where we just keep adding solution to dilute the original substance, how much would we get? Starting with a teaspoon of the original substance, a teaspoon is equal to 4.928922 x 10-6 cubic meters. Multiplied by 1 x 10030 and find for the volume of a sphere. My calculation shows a spherical volume with a radius of 490,028 km. The radius of the Earth is only 6,378.1 km!

Now you can see why I had my doubts that the makers of Homeopathic substances don't just keep dumping their entire resultant solutions into the next succession. There aren't that many customers! There isn't that much room on Earth! The resulting solution would have a radius 76 times greater than that of the Earth! Whew!
  1. Would it even be possible that a single molecule of the original material is left in any randomly sampled part of this mix? We could calculate it ... however paragraph 5 above saves us the trouble!
Higher potencies of homeopathic remedies (anything higher than 12C) have been diluted past the point that molecules of the original substance would be measurable in the solution. This is a major stumbling block for skeptics when it comes to understanding and accepting the idea of homeopathy.
"Major stumbling block?" My, they don't mince words do they? So how does this magic potion work if there is no longer any of the original material in it? The paragraph goes on to say that they don't know why it works, and mumbles some pseudoscientific crap about energy.

If you look around on the Internet, the best guess that anyone has is that the carrier liquid 'remembers' the influence of the original material that it was associated with. This is it. This is the best theory that anyone can come up with. Since most carrier liquids are plain distilled water, you have to wonder about this! Do they use municiple tap water? If so, how do they account for the impurities in this tap water that might affect treatment? Bottled distilled water? There are still impurities!

Do they make their own distilled water? If so, they will quickly discover that there exists NO METHOD AT ALL to make distilled water without some impurities! Homeopathy offers no explanation of how to 'clear' water memory. If water 'remembers' what it was in contact with, then it would be logical to assume that the water will remember touching the side of the container that it is being distilled in!

And just how good is water's memory? The Homeopathic community does not know! They can't know if water will remember impurities that it associated with decades, or millennia
ago! All water on Earth has gone through a biological cycle over and over again for millions and millions of years! What is this water able to remember? Just how therapeutic is Trilobite piss? Would we be wary of waste from Whale, Walrus, Worms or Wart Hogs?
Higher potencies of homeopathic remedies (anything higher than 12C)
Wait, something seems wrong here. Are they claiming that a more diluted substance has a higher potency than a lesser diluted substance? Yes! They ARE! The less the amount of original substance, the better it works. This again defies logic. (I get this wild thought that if I could achieve infinite dilution, the resultant potion should bring the dead back to life!)
Homeopathic remedies, when correctly chosen, clearly work
Really? They do? What proof is there for this? To see if this proof is valid, let's take a look at how Modern science is supposed to work:
  • Modern science is "Peer review" driven. This means that when one scientist makes a discovery, he writes up his findings and submits them to one (or several) science journals. His peers will read his work, and will attempt to duplicate his efforts. If any of his methods or findings seem questionable his peers will definitely attempt to duplicate his findings, and are happy to point out where his science fails.
  • Scientific results are repeatable. If a set of conditions give a certain result, then duplicating the conditions will give an identical result.
  • Scientists who test to see if a particular substance has an effect on people rely on a scientific method called a "double-blind" test. In these tests, the people being subjected to the test often have no idea what they are being tested for. At the very least, they have no idea if they are being given an active substance or a placebo. The person running the test also does not know what is being tested for, and also does not know if an active substance or a placebo is being given. The scientist that understands what is going on is not present during a double-blind test so that nothing is given away accidentally. All results, no matter how trivial, are recorded by people who don't know what is being tested for, and the raw data is then sorted out by the scientist.
So we can see that these methods of measuring results and having them reviewed by your peers is what makes science self-correcting. Science makes mistakes all the time! This is taken as given by any true scientist! But the methods of science result in the eventual correction of mistakes

So again, what proof is there that Homeopathic remedies work? If there is proof, it should be in a peer-reviewed medical journal, right? Luckily, as a student at California State University, Fresno; I have access to many on line scientific journals. I used the MEDLINE (Silverplatter) server which indexes more journals in health and medicine than any other server at my school. I then used "Homeopathic" as a keyword and started reading the resulting abstracts from various journals.

First I was shocked to find out that there are 'medical' journals for alternative medicine! Such as the Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine, or the Journal of the Faculty of Homeopathy! All of these so called 'scientific' journals start with the assumption that Homeopathy is a working, proven science! I'll take this opportunity to state that if science starts with a bias - if it does not operate from a neutral, objective standpoint, then said 'science' is only worthless crap. It is worse than worthless - it can be dangerous!

The next thing that I found is that the standard 'neutral' medical, biological, and biochemical journals seem to also be doing research into Homeopathy.

Just from a curious browse through the these abstracts I found that if the Journal seemed 'iffy' to me, in that it used the words "Homeopathic" or "Alternative" in the journal title, then for the most part the Homeopathic remedies under test were seen to have value, or were determined to act positively.

Abstracts from all other journals were very emphatic in their results in that Homeopathic remedies do not work, or at best were indeterminant!

Homeopathic supporters are quick to point out a 1986 Clinical study published in the mainstream British medical journal Lancet that indicates that Homeopathic remedies were effective in the treatment of 'allergic rhinitis'. I found this journal entry in Lancet. I also found another Lancet journal entry for 1997, about a Meta-analysis of Homeopathy, that said it:
... found insufficient evidence from these studies that homeopathy is clearly efficacious for any single clinical condition. Further research on homeopathy is warranted provided it is rigorous and systematic. (Lancet 1997 Sep 20; 350(9081): 834-43)
Well, that's not too bad - it seems to say that Homeopathic methods don't seem to work, but that further research should be done. Provided that the research is done scientifically.

But wait! Letters to the Lancet, as part of peer review, point out that the 1997 Meta-Analysis is severely flawed due to biases of the original tester, inappropriate use of statistics, and poorly acquired data. The letters say that the Meta-analysis has a biased positive viewpoint, and that Homeopathy has been shown to be worthless in many journals.


Lastly, I took a look at exactly WHAT the original article was supposed to be, and I found something that surprised me. The original 1986 'study' was not a Lancet article at all! Instead, it is only a 'letter' to Lancet detailing 'case-reports'. The Meta-analysis is an article, which resulted in peer-review. The original 1986 'letter' has been for the most part ignored as not worth a real response. The response is much the same as if someone had sent a letter to the editor of Scientifc American magazine saying that his blurry photos were proof of Bigfoot! It is somewhat valuable as humor, but no one will bother to respond to it!


This is the 'Proof' that Homeopathy works? How disappointing!

I have met people who claim that they have used Homeopatic remedies and who have said that these remedies worked for them. Good for them! But let me gently remind the reader that there is something called the 'placebo effect' too. The human mind is wonderfully able to create it's own drugs (called endorphins)

I have noticed that none of these people have claimed to use a Homeopathic remedy for such things as staunching severe (life-threatening) bleeding, or for reducing the pain and swelling of a broken arm. That would impress me!

I have yet to find a double-blind, repeatable, scientifically reviewed test that proves that Homeopatic remedies work. But maybe I'm wrong, eh? If you know of such a test, published in a mainstream medical journal, I would like to know.


I don't know how anyone else feels about this - but I find it disturbing that there are practicing witch-doctors in the United States that sell 'magic' potions to cure real ailments. There seems to be no proof that these treatments do anything more than make money for the witch-doctor in question.

If a seller of these potions believes that what he or she is doing is valid, then I would consider them to be mis-informed. If a person is doing this just for the money - well, that's just pathetic.

Maybe we should call this Homeopathetic medicine?