Friday in the atelier: "Cleopatra Testing Poisons on Condemned Prisoners" by Alexandre Cabanel

History and allegory have always been popular subjects for painters. It seems that during those times when expression was restricted to what was deemed “moral” painters who wished to paint nudes were often able to do so by associating them with a religious allegory, or by referencing a historical figure. In this context they could equate “nude” with “purity” and reduce their risk of incarceration or worse.

Historical paintings were often officially sanctioned because they were valued as a method of instruction. Incidentally, government endorsement was worth a great deal to the painter. I’m sure that at least a few lesser painters saw this as a gravy train, and tried to ingratiate themselves to their governments through works that embellished loved figures, or denigrated hated figures. To take liberties with a Winston Churchill quote, “History is painted by the victors.”

As I remarked in my last atelier entry, Jules Lefebvre made his name with the allegory of “Truth”. William Bouguereau also painted allegorical and historical paintings – “The Flagellation of Our Lord Jesus Christ” which I think is probably his best religious historical painting.

By the late 1800s art lovers in France were becoming jaded with history paintings. I can imagine why! The Salon de Paris, which held exhibitions twice a year, was picky about the artists who could exhibit their works. This led to frustrated artists who created splinter art exhibitions for styles such as Impressionism (Salon des Refusés), and for traditional, conservative artists (Salon du Champs de Mars). Smaller exhibitions were also prevalent as other groups formed.

So by the late 1800s it must have seemed like art exhibitions were held every other week in France. And historical and allegorical paintings were in all of these exhibitions, often painted by artists who tried to play the system with historical art in order to make money. Connoisseurs of fine art took to calling historical paintings, “Firemen Art” (L'art pompier) as a derisive label – the label came from the Greek style helmets worn in the paintings, which looked similar to the horse-tail helmets that were worn by French firemen. The name was later used by 20th century critics to sneer at all such work, regardless of the quality of the artist.


The painting I’m displaying today is a historical painting that may have been dismissed at one time as L’art pompier. The painting is Alexandre Cabanel’sCleopatra Testing Poisons on Condemned Prisoners" As usual, this is a cropped detail – click on the image to see it in full.

I only like a few of Cabanel’s paintings; sometimes the faces in his paintings have too much of a Renaissance style for my tastes. He also wasn’t as interested in painting “beauty” as Bouguereau, so seems to me that some of his best work is of mediocre people. Even so he was very skilled, and he is an important artist to know because he taught painting, and through his teaching he influenced hundreds of pupils who did paint “beauty”. The works of Cabanel’s students had a huge impact on the French “Beautiful Era” (Belle Époque).

Cabanel was born in 1823. When he was 17 he entered the National School of Fine Arts in Paris. He first exhibited his paintings at the Salon de Paris at the age of 21, and won the Grand Prix de Rome scholarship at the age of 22, which allowed him to study at the French Academy of Fine Arts. At the age of 40 Cabanel created the famous painting "The Birth of Venus" which helped win his appointment as a professor at the School of Fine Arts in Paris, and assured his place in history.

Cabanel won the Grand Medal of Honor three different years at the Salon de Paris exhibitions of 1865, 1867, and 1878, and he was elected time and again to sit on the Salon de Paris jury.


As for this particular history painting, stories and history about Cleopatra always include accounts of poison. One of Cleopatra’s older sisters tried to poison her; her younger brother (and co-ruler of Egypt) died mysteriously – probably poisoned – leaving Cleopatra in charge; (although she did appoint her son from Julies Caesar to be her male co-ruler.) Cleopatra was more than somewhat familiar with poison, and Cabanel’s painting illustrates a possible method that she may have used to increase her knowledge. This painting shows a coldly interested Cleopatra watching as various poisons are tried on prisoners condemned to death.

She’s beautiful, and she’s as deadly as the asp that was said to kill her. I think Cabanel shows this very well.

3 comments:

John said...

What I love about Cabanel's work is that his figures are always in motion. Bouguereau's figures, for all their beauty, have a certain stillness to them -- a slight element of artificiality that suggests that they were created in a studio and not en plein air. Cabanel's figures are more vibrant, more active, more fluid. Like this one. The viewer (or this one, anyway) is left with the impression that the nymph is about to faint off the canvas.

Calladus said...

I don't know, Cabanel's figure paintings are often posed in the "thousand yard stare" which sort of lends them to seeming a bit unreal.

And something about "La Comtesse de Keller" makes me seriously dislike the poor woman, even though I've no clue who she is.

I do love Cabanel's "Ophelia" and "Paige" and "The Roman Monk". These seem real to me, more spontaneous, and not so 'posed'.

Don't get me wrong, I love Cabanel's work - and am seriously impressed by how many artists he trained. He seems to have touched everyone.

Unlike some of the other artists I've written about, there are some paintings in his folio that don't impress me - but that's a matter of my own taste.

If Cabanel was a rock star, I'd buy his worst-sounding full length CD just to get to the one song that I love.

John said...

That's a good analogy. Sort of like how Babe Ruth rarely hit the ball, but when he did, it was a homer.

If you enjoy Cabanel, you might also like Solomon Joseph Solomon, one of his students. His figures display the same fluidity of Cabanel's.